Cigar Thread

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

soonerwings

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Jun 16, 2009
Messages
2,199
Reaction score
472
Location
McClain County
All right boys and girls, here goes. I thought it would be somewhat diverting to start an ongoing thread where we could all post up reviews of the stogies we'd recently smoked and of cigar gadgets we'd tried. As time goes by, I'll probably try to devise a standard template for my reviews, but as for tonight I'm just gonna let it rip and see how it turns out.

Before I jump into the review of tonight's stogie, I feel compelled to say a word or two about a new cutter that I got for Christmas. It's a Xikar V cutter and I have to say that I am most impressed. I've been a die hard punch cutter for years and this thing has changed my mind. With the V cut you get more surface area on the cut (which in my experience thus far has greatly enhanced my ability to pick out flavors) while still getting a nice smooth mouth feel that you get from a punch. It's bulky, but light, and doubles as a cigar rest when turned over. Very cool.

Tonight's stogie was a Man O' War Orange County Choppers that I've been wanting to try for a long time. It's been resting in the humi for three weeks at 65%.

Wrapper: The wrapper on this thing is impressive. It's a very dark, veiny, and thick wrapper with a ton of tooth. If it's possible for a cigar to make someone look like a badass, this one should do the trick.

Cold draw: On the cold draw, the cigar gives a sort of sweet hay/black cherry flavor.

Flavor: After the cigar heats up, there's no hint of the black cherry like I was hoping for. Rather, there's a slight tobacco sweetness with a lot of black pepper zing. The stick leaves a slight oiliness on your lips while smoking that burns a bit. I dig that but really like a bit more sweetness.

Smoke production: The OCC edition produces a TON of thick chewy smoke.

Draw: In my mind, it's perfect. That being said, I prefer a loose draw so some of you might find the draw to be a bit loose.

Burn: Like every other AJ Fernandez cigar, this thing has a razor sharp burn line. Absolutely no corrections are needed.

Body: This one is definitely a full bodied smoke, similar to the Ruination.

Strength: I'm going to say this one reminds me of the old Beavis and Butthead episode where they were trying to lift weights and screaming "kick me in the jimmy." Even after a full meal, this one kicked me in the jimmy. After finishing the smoke with a glass of red wine, I thought I might be levitating a bit.

Smoke time: This was a 6.5 x 52 stick and I only managed an hour and twenty minutes. I tend to smoke a bit fast, but I still get over an hour and a half to an hour forty five out of similar sized sticks. It may have been packed a bit loose which could explain the perfect loose draw.

Overall impression: It's far from being a bad smoke, but I like a bit more sweetness when I smoke something with that much spice. Still, it was a nice smoking experience and worth the $5 I got it for on Cigarbid.
 

jalapeno

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Mar 23, 2009
Messages
644
Reaction score
2
Location
mcloud
Ok I will participate, let me start by saying my preferred cigar usually starts with a Connecticut wrapper and is on the lighter side. I tend to stay away from the maduro wrappers.

My latest was a Davidoff Nicaragua diadema

Wrapper: The wrapper is natural
Cold draw: it starts off peppery and carries through to the end.
Flavor: it is peppery with a hint of leather but not overpowering. it grows stronger toward the end but never becomes too much.
Smoke production: Nice full smoke.
Draw: loose, but i like a loose draw.
Burn: nice burn line all the way to the end.
Body: this is listed as a medium body smoke but i would say it is on the upper end of medium.
Strength: strong but pleasant, it will levitate you if you are not used to a strong cigar.
Smoke time: This was a 6.5 x 50 hour and a half.
Overall impression: find a spot to sit down with a good drink, send the wife and kids off shopping or something and take your time with this one. its a good smoke but I likes the davidoff Nicaragua torro much better. most wont like the price of this one at $18.50 and if you like a lighter cigar the davidoff anivesario NO. 1 is excellent.
 

soonerwings

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Jun 16, 2009
Messages
2,199
Reaction score
472
Location
McClain County
Ok I will participate, let me start by saying my preferred cigar usually starts with a Connecticut wrapper and is on the lighter side. I tend to stay away from the maduro wrappers.

My latest was a Davidoff Nicaragua diadema

Wrapper: The wrapper is natural
Cold draw: it starts off peppery and carries through to the end.
Flavor: it is peppery with a hint of leather but not overpowering. it grows stronger toward the end but never becomes too much.
Smoke production: Nice full smoke.
Draw: loose, but i like a loose draw.
Burn: nice burn line all the way to the end.
Body: this is listed as a medium body smoke but i would say it is on the upper end of medium.
Strength: strong but pleasant, it will levitate you if you are not used to a strong cigar.
Smoke time: This was a 6.5 x 50 hour and a half.
Overall impression: find a spot to sit down with a good drink, send the wife and kids off shopping or something and take your time with this one. its a good smoke but I likes the davidoff Nicaragua torro much better. most wont like the price of this one at $18.50 and if you like a lighter cigar the davidoff anivesario NO. 1 is excellent.

Very nice! I've been meaning to try the Nicaraguan Davidoff for a while but haven't done it yet. $18 is a bit steep for an every day cigar, but I don't mind throwing down a bit of cash for a nice stick every now and then. For me, it's usually an Ashton VSG or ESG. My go to stick for an inexpensive Connecticut is the Man o War Virtue or a Monte Classic.
 

jalapeno

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Mar 23, 2009
Messages
644
Reaction score
2
Location
mcloud
Very nice! I've been meaning to try the Nicaraguan Davidoff for a while but haven't done it yet. $18 is a bit steep for an every day cigar, but I don't mind throwing down a bit of cash for a nice stick every now and then. For me, it's usually an Ashton VSG or ESG. My go to stick for an inexpensive Connecticut is the Man o War Virtue or a Monte Classic.

I highly suggest the torro it was one of the best i have ever had. cigar aficionado rated it no.3 in 2013. yeah $18 is not an everyday but like you I am not against throwing down some cash once in a while to enjoy a good smoke. I have tried a couple of the ashton's but they have been hit or miss for me I will give the VSG and ESG a try, and the Man O War. maybe if this thread takes off we can grid something out for price/strength and I would love to hear some opinions on cigar stores as well both local, online, and in other cities. one I have recently found is Tabaco lane on the square in Ft worth. Nice store the lady behind the counter was very helpful and knowledgeable. large walk in humidor and a wine area in the back, so they had something for me and the wife.
 

gunnut

Sharpshooter
Joined
Jan 1, 2008
Messages
1,115
Reaction score
7
Location
Choctaw
Cigar Aficionado and their ratings can suck it. After smoking some of their highly rated cigars, I don't put a lot of credence in their reviews anymore.
 

p238shooter

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Aug 16, 2012
Messages
3,681
Reaction score
2,878
Location
East of Tulsa
This was interesting reading as I have been doing cigars for over thirty years. Most people would not recognize me with out one hanging out my mouth. But, then this thread went off sideways. Putting fire to them and making smoke? Not for me.

I love the smell of a good cigar, but I do not like to smoke them. I chew them most of my awake life. I will be watching this thread, looking for a good chewer. I had an "imported" from some other country Cuban cigar once that had an almost green wrapper, fat and very moist. One of the best chewers I have ever had.

Any one else just chew them, or light them and let them go out and really do not care?

I do not intend to hijack your thread, but since I most likely purchase a larger number of cigars than anyone else here, just wondering. We love Cigars. I was told Jose Melendi, Rothchild in the wooden box just shut down production by one supplier. Got to do some more checking.
 

lkothe

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Jul 13, 2013
Messages
1,272
Reaction score
25
Location
collinsville ok
I also chew cigars. Never been one to smoke but am enjoying the flavors and scents of cigars.
Not much into expensive sticks.....nice aroma and full flavor works fine for me.
 

jalapeno

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Mar 23, 2009
Messages
644
Reaction score
2
Location
mcloud
not much on chewing them, but I would think maybe you might like some of the flavored cigars i know there are some chocolate and vanilla flavored along with the rum and bandy dipped.
 

Cohiba

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Oct 3, 2007
Messages
3,977
Reaction score
894
Location
Part time Vegas, Galveston, Oklahoma
As of 2.........almost 3 years now, I've been smoking a very mild and elegant cigar.


Fonseca Cosacos/Silk Wrapped.........really it's more like paper. They're not that big.......5 2/5 x42 and pair with Jack & Coke, Maker's Mark & 7-Up, Fighting Cock and either Coke or 7-Up, or George Dickel#12 neat or mixed. Just a nice, mild, talking with your buddies kind of smoke with a mild flavor.


www.cigarone.com_photos_paradise_VINTAGE_CIGARS_FONSECA_Cosacos.jpg
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom