Private roads - engineering/construction/maintenance

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

-Pjackso

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Jun 25, 2009
Messages
1,088
Reaction score
860
Location
OKC
Hi All,
Does anyone have good references for engineering specifications for roads?


I live in an HOA association with private (paved) roads. The HOA roads-committee does a good job trying to manage the roads, although none of them have a background in 'roads'.

A majority of our roads are in good condition, with the occasional places that's failing. The failing portions are where the road-base is too soft and can't support the loading. Hence the ground sinks/ pavement cracks/and hence - fails in certain locations. I think the original contractor (in the 80's) just put down pavement on the dirt, and hoped for the best. We currently have (2) overlays of pavement, so it's a sizeable thickness. It's worked so far.

The conventional approach for road damage is to ask for a pavement company to quote a repair. That's fine for spot-repairs, but we have a short road that needs full-repair. Unfortunately, nobody in the HOA has any idea what specifications to require for base re-construction. We don't need to over-design the repair ($$$), and also not under-design it either. ...And trusting the salesman isn't always the most prudent approach.

Usage includes personal traffic, garbage trucks, occasional lawn services, utility/boat trailers.
I'd say the normal traffic within a home association.


I have a Mechanical Engineering background, but not so much in Civil Engineering. I have offered to provide my help to the HOA roads-committee, and need to get up to speed on the subject.
For the Civil Engineering/DOT folks, can you please direct me to some good references?



Q: What's the difference between a Mechanical Engineer and a Civil Engineer?
A: Mechanical Engineers build the bombs. Civil Engineers build the targets.
 
Last edited:

rickm

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Aug 14, 2012
Messages
2,988
Reaction score
3,838
Location
Durant
To save you some money you might get in touch with the local municipality street maintenance personnel or county and ask their recommendations on what needs to be done and if they could give you a list of contractors that they recommend.
 

JeffT

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Feb 25, 2010
Messages
648
Reaction score
428
Location
Piedmont
TJ Campbell, Atlas, Bishop Paving those three have all done work that I’ve seen. All three are solid companies that did good jobs that have held up over time.


Live Simply, Love Generously, Care Deeply, Speak Kindly, Shoot Well, Leave the rest to God.
 

Buzzdraw

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Dec 14, 2005
Messages
3,271
Reaction score
176
Location
NE Oklahoma
Surely someone in the HOA knows a CE who could give a little advice for a nice BBQ meal.

I have a little experience in private roads. I'd suggest the HOA build to handle the heaviest loads permitted on their roads under soaked ground conditions. Post signage per axle and enforce. A fully loaded 10 wheeler trash truck is pretty heavy. A concrete truck, fully loaded is also pretty heavy. Hard to regulate trash truck loads but easier to limit concrete truck weights per axle.

If the road base is solid and water drains away from the roadway then a topcoat will last a while. If holes keep developing in the same spots then the base under it is poor. Fix it before topcoat.
 

Parks 788

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Oct 13, 2010
Messages
3,103
Reaction score
2,907
Location
Bristow, OK
I'd see if anyone in the HOA is a general contractor for a larger developer or commercial contractor. If so, they will have a list of past asphalt contractors that have done a good job for them doing repairs, street work or parking lot work. I would see if he can provide several contractors you could talk to. I wouldn't talk to the sales guys at the asphalt company but would see if you can meet with one of their superintendents or General Foremans for advice. THese guy are actually more knowledgeable than the sales guys and have hands on experience.
 

Jwryan84

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Sep 15, 2009
Messages
3,286
Reaction score
681
Location
NW OKC
Hi All,
Does anyone have good references for engineering specifications for roads?


I live in an HOA association with private (paved) roads. The HOA roads-committee does a good job trying to manage the roads, although none of them have a background in 'roads'.

A majority of our roads are in good condition, with the occasional places that's failing. The failing portions are where the road-base is too soft and can't support the loading. Hence the ground sinks/ pavement cracks/and hence - fails in certain locations. I think the original contractor (in the 80's) just put down pavement on the dirt, and hoped for the best. We currently have (2) overlays of pavement, so it's a sizeable thickness. It's worked so far.

The conventional approach for road damage is to ask for a pavement company to quote a repair. That's fine for spot-repairs, but we have a short road that needs full-repair. Unfortunately, nobody in the HOA has any idea what specifications to require for base re-construction. We don't need to over-design the repair ($$$), and also not under-design it either. ...And trusting the salesman isn't always the most prudent approach.

Usage includes personal traffic, garbage trucks, occasional lawn services, utility/boat trailers.
I'd say the normal traffic within a home association.


I have a Mechanical Engineering background, but not so much in Civil Engineering. I have offered to provide my help to the HOA roads-committee, and need to get up to speed on the subject.
For the Civil Engineering/DOT folks, can you please direct me to some good references?



Q: What's the difference between a Mechanical Engineer and a Civil Engineer?
A: Mechanical Engineers build the bombs. Civil Engineers build the targets.


Northwood? Just moved out here and having the same issues.
 

Apogee

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Feb 7, 2013
Messages
384
Reaction score
70
Location
OKC
They did this in my neighborhood, don't know specs. Wound up completely taking out the old road, laid down fly ash (huge mess, it gets everywhere), then actual road base material (which looks like a combo of sand, dirt, and different sized aggregate) then a base coat of asphalt, then a top coat. For 2 lane miles cost was approx $600,000. Roads have held up well, there have still been a few repairs, and just a couple of years ago they had the roads sealed to help extend the life. The have discussed that the re-sealing will be an ongoing thing every few years to help extend the life. Will inquire with HOA to see if someone remembers specs they asked for.
 

Snattlerake

Conservitum Americum
Special Hen
Joined
Jan 19, 2019
Messages
20,602
Reaction score
32,096
Location
OKC
Q: What's the difference between a Mechanical Engineer and a Civil Engineer?
A: Mechanical Engineers build the bombs. Civil Engineers build the targets.

An aeronautical engineer is the middleman.
 

SoonerP226

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Jan 1, 2013
Messages
13,520
Reaction score
14,047
Location
Norman
Call your county commissioner's office and see if you can talk to the person in charge of road maintenance, preferably the guy in charge of engineering. They should be able to at least point you in the right direction. I'd suggest ODOT, but I'm thinking you'd have a better chance of getting to talk to someone at the county level.
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom