Oklahoma Earthquake Politics

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Hobbes

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Mar 5, 2008
Messages
8,738
Reaction score
749
Location
The Nations
It's a long article that will exceed the limit on the forum so I will post a link to it and some relevant portions.


Oklahoma's state scientists have suspected for years that oil and gas operations in the state were causing a swarm of earthquakes, but in public they rejected such a connection.

When the Oklahoma Geological Survey (OGS) did cautiously agree with other scientists about such a link, emails obtained by EnergyWire show the state seismologist was called into meetings with his boss, University of Oklahoma President David Boren, and oil executives "concerned" about the acknowledgement.

One of the oilmen was Continental Resources Chairman Harold Hamm, a leading donor to the university.

The seismologist, Austin Holland, told a senior U.S. Geological Survey official that as far back as 2010, OGS officials believed an earthquake swarm near Oklahoma City might have been triggered by the "Hunton dewatering," an oil and gas project east of the city.

"Since early 2010 we have recognized the potential for the Jones earthquake swarm to be due to the Hunton dewatering," Holland wrote to USGS science adviser Bill Leith in 2013. "But until we can demonstrate that scientifically or not we were not going to discuss that publicly."
Instead, he pointed to changing lake levels.
...

Federal and academic seismologists say the wave of shaking in Oklahoma and other central states is not from "natural earthquakes." They link it to disposal of wastewater by oil and gas companies.

"This rise in seismic activity, especially in the central United States, is not the result of natural processes," USGS said in a recent release. "Deep injection of wastewater is the primary cause of the dramatic rise in detected earthquakes and the corresponding increase in seismic hazard in the central U.S."

Oklahoma's top elected officials have avoided talking about the state's earthquake swarms, leaving the response largely to Holland, 40, who joined OGS in 2010. No other state official has done as many television and news interviews about earthquakes.

The agency's 2012 annual report quipped that "Holland seems to be on everyone's speed dial when the ground starts shaking."
...

In the fall of 2013, though, OGS edged toward acknowledging a link between the state's earthquakes and its oil and gas industry. That's when Hamm and other Oklahoma leaders took a personal interest.

In September 2013, earthquakes started to rattle Marietta, a small town in southern Oklahoma near the site of a new disposal well. Holland investigated, and his preliminary report focused on the correlation between disposal operations and the earthquakes. He has not published a final report, but it's the closest OGS has come to linking earthquakes to a specific well.

In October 2013, OGS joined in a USGS statement about the growing seismic risk in Oklahoma. Under the OGS seal, it said "activities such as wastewater disposal" may be a "contributing factor to the increase in earthquakes."

Industry leaders were not pleased.

Holland was summoned a week later to the headquarters of the Oklahoma Corporation Commission (OCC) with Jack Stark, who was then senior vice president of exploration with Continental Resources. Stark is now president and chief operating officer. OCC, overseen by three statewide elected commissioners, regulates oil and gas in the state. The meeting was in the office of then-Commissioner Patrice Douglas.

Douglas and the Continental executive were "concerned" about the joint statement with USGS and a story about it by EnergyWire, Holland recounted later in an email (EnergyWire, Oct. 25, 2013). Holland wrote that he had tried to explain to them that the joint statement was "made better" by his input.

"Continental does not feel induced seismicity is an issue and they are nervous about any dialog about the subject," Holland wrote to his bosses after the 2013 meeting. "They are in the denial phase that this is a possibility."

At the time, Douglas was about to run for Congress. She got more campaign money from Continental executives in 2014 than anyone except Sen. James Lankford (R-Okla.) and the Republican National Committee, according to OpenSecrets.org. The $14,775 she received from Continental includes $6,575 from Hamm, who did not contribute to her Republican primary opponent, Steve Russell. Russell beat Douglas in the primary and is now a congressman.

In the meeting, Douglas said she "wants to, of course, protect the safety of Oklahomans, but also balance that with industry in the state," according to Holland's email.
Holland "blind copied" himself on the email.

The meeting with Hamm and Boren was about three weeks later.

"I have been asked to have 'coffee' with President Boren and Harold Hamm Wednesday," he wrote in an Nov. 18, 2013, email to a co-worker.
The significance was not lost on his colleague, OGS Public Information Coordinator Connie Smith.

"Gosh," Smith responded. "I guess that's better than having Kool-Aid with them. I guess."
A meeting with such powerful figures in the state would be intimidating for a state employee such as Holland, said state Rep. Jason Murphey of Guthrie.
"Wow. That's a lot of pressure," said Murphey, a Republican whose district has been rattled by numerous quakes. "That just sends chills up your spine if you're from Oklahoma."
Hamm is the chairman and CEO of Continental. But as the founder of the company, he's much more than that.
...
Perhaps more relevant to Boren and Holland is Hamm's relationship to the university. In March 2011, Boren declared Hamm's $20 million gift launching the Harold Hamm Oklahoma Diabetes Center "the largest single gift in the history of the Health Sciences Center."
...
After the meeting with Stark, a long-standing swarm of earthquakes northeast of Oklahoma City expanded to the north and grew stronger. The Jones swarm had been rattling the area for several years at that point.

Holland, though, downplayed any connection to the Hunton Dewatering project. In a television interview at the time, he pointed toward natural causes (EnergyWire, Nov. 4, 2013). In a scientific posting, he pointed at changing water levels at a nearby lake (EnergyWire, Nov. 14, 2013).
...
Holland replied that he was "quite skeptical myself" of such a link. But he said reporters asked him about it, so "my hand was forced on this matter." He added that the agency had suspected ties between the Jones quakes and Hunton production for three years, but had been reluctant to discuss it publicly.
...

In a media outing earlier this year, Holland acknowledged to reporters from the Tulsa World, The New York Times and The Washington Post that the industry has tried to influence his work.

"I can't really talk about it," Holland told the reporters. "We're going to do the right thing."

But Bob Jackman says Holland did talk about it last year and indicated that it was Hamm who was leaning on him.

Jackman is a Tulsa petroleum geologist who has made himself a thorn in the side of Oklahoma's establishment on issues such as earthquakes. In an opinion journal article last year, Jackman described approaching Holland about earthquakes after a conference in September.

Jackman said he pressed him about earthquakes until Holland blurted out, "You don't understand -- Harold Hamm and others will not allow me to say certain things."
 

Dale00

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
May 28, 2006
Messages
7,462
Reaction score
3,868
Location
Oklahoma
Provocative article and reporting. Thanks.

The president of a major university appears to be a well paid member of the board of directors of a company that is potentially adversely impacted by the research of one of the faculty members of the same university. He calls in the faculty member to have coffee with the president of the company impacted by the research. hmm...
 

1krr

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Jul 10, 2006
Messages
721
Reaction score
1
Location
OK Shooters
Worst part is I just heard on the news that out of 100 earthquake related insurance claims in 2014, only 8 were paid. Most insurance companies, even if they will insure earthquake damage have clauses about manmade events and specifically call out oil/gas activities. O/G has been throwing their hands up and denying it for years just like tobacco denied for years that cigarettes cause cancer. What's going to happen is they are going to end up getting sued into oblivion.
 

SoonerP226

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Jan 1, 2013
Messages
13,438
Reaction score
13,855
Location
Norman
The president of a major university appears to be a well paid member of the board of directors of a company that is potentially adversely impacted by the research of one of the faculty members of the same university. He calls in the faculty member to have coffee with the president of the company impacted by the research. hmm...
FWIW, Holland is not a faculty member at OU. He might be an adjunct, but he's in a staff position at OGS (which is a "constituent agency" of OU), not on the faculty. It's an important distinction because staff appointments don't carry the same protections as tenure-track faculty appointments--with the exception of the coaches and a few key administrators (who are on contracts), all staff at OU are "at will" employees.
 

30BulletHoles

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Jun 17, 2009
Messages
1,721
Reaction score
80
Location
Woodward
Worst part is I just heard on the news that out of 100 earthquake related insurance claims in 2014, only 8 were paid. Most insurance companies, even if they will insure earthquake damage have clauses about manmade events and specifically call out oil/gas activities. O/G has been throwing their hands up and denying it for years just like tobacco denied for years that cigarettes cause cancer. What's going to happen is they are going to end up getting sued into oblivion.

I guess some people need to read their policy before purchasing.
 

dennishoddy

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Dec 9, 2008
Messages
84,556
Reaction score
61,838
Location
Ponca City Ok
One can only hope. Recent developments in the energy sector have shown how critically Oklahoma needs to diversify it's economy anyway.

Oklahoma has known for many years after boom and bust years that we need to do this. At least the Politicians say they do.

In reality at a local level, Ponca City has been pretty successful at attracting some small business, but a friend of mine that runs the program, says the big dogs that run the companies are the obstacle.

No matter how many tax incentives they get, the CEO staff does not want to move from Dallas to a small town. They need the high life that small town businesses can't offer.


There are exceptions when the big dogs can stay in the big cities. IE, some of the auto industries in the SE, but I believe that is the norm.
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom