Input Appreciated Sig P365X or G43X

[okierider]

My son has the XL, great pistol , I just feel the grip is a little small for me and ended up with the Shield plus.

 

[HFS]

Before investing that much, I would see if I could shoot both of them (maybe find a range that rents them).
I've found out "oh heck no!" when I shot a gun I thought I would like.
It costs range time, rental fee and ammo but may be cheaper in the long run.
I don't know much about the 10 round/12 round/15 round magazine controversy but I'd also look at the price of spare magazines, a different set of sights (if that's on the menu), etc.
The price of spare mags for some guns these days has sent me running the other way on a couple of occasions.

 

[bigred1]

Sig has the better trigger.

 

[O4L]

My large hands prefer the 43X/48 grip.

It's best to try both and go with the one you shoot the best.

 

[thor447]

Can’t go wrong with either. I’ve carried the 43X, and several others mentioned here earlier. Now I am carrying the 365X. I think this one is a keeper. Nothing wrong with any of them. It’s just a matter of personal choice for me in the way in which I carry and the 365X checks all the boxes for me.

 

[RagdollOp]

I shot the P365 and the Glock 43 back to back. For me the P365 was better in everyway. I ended up buying the P365. I haven't shot p365xl or the 43x but I love that I can change everything on the P365. Its so modular and with the trigger control group being the actual gun it makes swapping things easy. I plan to get a P365xl grip for my p365 and try it. I heard its great.

 

[Pstmstr]

365 currently. You might want to consider a 43 with the new Shield mags coming out. For me, quite a bit of difference in conceal ability between 43 and 43x.

 

[rj ︈]

48 or 365XL are easier to conceal in your waistband if you’re using a holster. If you want something smaller, try the standard 43 or P365.

The 43X and 365X shouldn’t even exist.

 

[PanhandleGlocker]

48 or 365XL are easier to conceal in your waistband if you’re using a holster. If you want something smaller, try the standard 43 or P365.

The 43X and 365X shouldn’t even exist.

I like the shorter slide of the 43x compared to the 48

 

[GlockPride]

Checks username. Doesn’t own a single one nowadays. The Glock was never a contender this time last year when I bought the P365XL. Almost looked at HeckKitty, but the trigger wasn’t as good and mag drop was a problem due to hand placement.