Is anyone else tired of the "My pistol isn't accurate" threads?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

dennishoddy

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Dec 9, 2008
Messages
84,556
Reaction score
61,836
Location
Ponca City Ok
My pistol gets really inaccurate from time to time.

seems like when I start putting more rounds through it over time it gets more accurate. Like magic or something.
Truer words have never been spoken.
No different than a piano player or a welder.
Step away for awhile and it takes lots of practice to get back to the previous level.
It ain’t always the pistol. Soooo many variables involved in accurate pistol shooting. Grip is probably #1.
 

El Pablo

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Apr 5, 2007
Messages
7,958
Reaction score
8,778
Location
Yukon
I shoot better with doubling up hearing protection. I start flinching from noise, not recoil. Still hate loud noises and always have, but still have great hearing for a middle aged male because of it.

My p220 shot great at the last ens when suppressed and the suppressor blocking the sight picture.

I have had a few pistols with misaligned sights or the gunsmith put on the wrong height front sight on a 1911. They were still precise but not accurate until fixed. You couldn’t hit paper at 7 yards with the 1911 without aiming above it. Front sight was way to tall for the rear sight.

Vast majority of the time, it’s me, not the pistol.
 

V98

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Mar 2, 2020
Messages
250
Reaction score
476
Location
Oklahoma
I can shoot a pistol fairly well. Enough that I don't need to boast on the internet, but to qualify my experience; I've shot multiple service pistol matches at the Division Matches and below level. I also held the secondary MOS of Primary Marksmanship Instructor/Combat Marksmanship Trainer for 17 of my 21 years in the Corps. I also have reloaded for decades.

I will absolutely go on record as stating that I have some revolvers and pistols that very much prefer specific bullet weights and velocity nodes. It is just like a rifle...only most people aren't good enough to tell much of a difference. If they walked up to the line and shot a 6" group at 25 yards they'd be happy...and probably never notice the difference between a load that could shoot 1.5" and another that was only good for 4" at that distance.

My most extreme example: I have an original 1994 Colt King Cobra Enhanced that will shotgun pattern 125gr bullets at moderate to heavy magnum load velocities...yet that same revolver will shoot to the best of my capabilities with 158gr bullets at 38SPL velocities. It isn't a crimp or jacket separation issue, that revolver just has a very specific preference (and not all do...just like rifle barrels).

Ever notice how most of the handgun rags always seem to have better accuracy with SD ammo than bulk stuff?

Now, I realize that this goes against the gist of the OP. I totally understand the difference of a bad group due to ammo, and a shooter who lacks skill and training...and then complains when perfection isn't achieved. I'm not arguing against that...I'm just stating that SOMETIMES, it isn't always the Indian. Sometimes we need to give people the benefit of the doubt before assuming they're an idiot who can't shoot.

^ Now I'll basically contradict myself that 95% of the time, it's usually the Indian :D.
You are 100% correct and I’ll add this to what I posted earlier:

To a scratch golfer equipment makes a difference.

To an experienced, avid fisherman, equipment makes a difference.

To an archery marksman, avid clays shooter, etc. equipment makes a difference.

In the case of an average ordinary amateur, extraordinary equipment isn’t going to make them significantly better.

Maybe a little poorer but not significantly better!
 

Woodman 59

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Apr 7, 2021
Messages
577
Reaction score
689
Location
73107
Just today I was doing my morning surf of 5 forums I peruse,,,
I counted 9 (yes 9) threads where the poster said my pistol isn't accurate.

People then start recommending all sorts of goodies to correct that,,,
Everything from changing grips to changing the type of sights.

I say it's never (well almost never) the pistol that has an accuracy problem,,,
It's always (well almost always) the shooter.

Several years ago a friend of mine bought his first handgun,,,
It was the longer barreled version of the Ruger SR-22.

He joined an indoor range and fired one 50 round box of ammo,,,
At 25 yards he hit the 8" by 10" target about 5 times.

Then I had to listen to him complain that I recommended an inaccurate pistol.

We went to his range and I shot the pistol,,,
I'm no Annie Oakley but I did put all 20 rounds on paper.

Then the range master gave it a try,,,
He made a nice tight 10 round group around the bullseye.

My friend still believed it was the pistols fault and not his,,,
Mind you this is a man who had fired a total of (maybe) 200 rounds through my pistols.

He just couldn't accept the fact it was,,,
"The Indian not the arrow".

I guess he had seen enough TV and Movies to believe,,,
He should be a handgun sniper just by nature.

When I am asked by anyone what is the best accessory to improve accuracy,,,
My answer is always, "A 500 round brick of ammo and 1-hour of quality range instruction".

I'm not all angry about this,,,
I mean what would be the sense in that,,,
I just felt the desire to comment on the situation.

I'm a reasonable shot with a handgun,,,
But it isn't because I have the best accessories,,,
It's because I shoot a lot of ammo practicing at the range.

Aarond

.
Like most things the more you use it the more conformable you are with it and the easier it is to use.
 

Snattlerake

Conservitum Americum
Special Hen
Joined
Jan 19, 2019
Messages
20,444
Reaction score
31,736
Location
OKC
You are 100% correct and I’ll add this to what I posted earlier:

To a scratch golfer equipment makes a difference.

To an experienced, avid fisherman, equipment makes a difference.

To an archery marksman, avid clays shooter, etc. equipment makes a difference.

In the case of an average ordinary amateur, extraordinary equipment isn’t going to make them significantly better.

Maybe a little poorer but not significantly better!
I will challenge the golf equipment. I bought a set of cloned Ping Eye 2 clubs and because of my height had them put 1 inch longer shafts on every club. I improved my game exponentially. Equipment that fits is step one.
 

mavs

Sharpshooter
Special Hen Banned
Joined
Jun 5, 2021
Messages
1,105
Reaction score
1,013
Location
Texas
I will challenge the golf equipment. I bought a set of cloned Ping Eye 2 clubs and because of my height had them put 1 inch longer shafts on every club. I improved my game exponentially. Equipment that fits is step one.
So, what was your handicap before you bought the clubs, and then after you bought the clubs?
 

diggler1833

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Jul 7, 2021
Messages
864
Reaction score
2,049
Location
Southeast
I will challenge the golf equipment. I bought a set of cloned Ping Eye 2 clubs and because of my height had them put 1 inch longer shafts on every club. I improved my game exponentially. Equipment that fits is step one.

^ This relates to handgun accuracy much more than many people think. It can be overcome some with proper techniques and grip adjustment, but to force everyone to be as proficient with one design is unrealistic.

Maybe that's why we see so many exotic grip shapes on target pistols/revolvers (rhetorical)?

This is where some of time time it is the arrow and not the Indian. Yes, you can train proficiency back into it, but to assume that everyone has the time, money, and passion to undertake this is also unrealistic.

* I am not directing my comments toward you in any way, but I wanted to use your example to qualify my position a bit.

I probably should have included this with my long ramble about preferred loads, but the post was getting extremely long-winded already by that point.

Next we can go over sights, as some people aren't blessed with the vision to pick up a good sight picture like everyone else...
 

leemozoid

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
1,247
Reaction score
976
Location
Blanchard
Just today I was doing my morning surf of 5 forums I peruse,,,
I counted 9 (yes 9) threads where the poster said my pistol isn't accurate.

People then start recommending all sorts of goodies to correct that,,,
Everything from changing grips to changing the type of sights.

I say it's never (well almost never) the pistol that has an accuracy problem,,,
It's always (well almost always) the shooter.

Several years ago a friend of mine bought his first handgun,,,
It was the longer barreled version of the Ruger SR-22.

He joined an indoor range and fired one 50 round box of ammo,,,
At 25 yards he hit the 8" by 10" target about 5 times.

Then I had to listen to him complain that I recommended an inaccurate pistol.

We went to his range and I shot the pistol,,,
I'm no Annie Oakley but I did put all 20 rounds on paper.

Then the range master gave it a try,,,
He made a nice tight 10 round group around the bullseye.

My friend still believed it was the pistols fault and not his,,,
Mind you this is a man who had fired a total of (maybe) 200 rounds through my pistols.

He just couldn't accept the fact it was,,,
"The Indian not the arrow".

I guess he had seen enough TV and Movies to believe,,,
He should be a handgun sniper just by nature.

When I am asked by anyone what is the best accessory to improve accuracy,,,
My answer is always, "A 500 round brick of ammo and 1-hour of quality range instruction".

I'm not all angry about this,,,
I mean what would be the sense in that,,,
I just felt the desire to comment on the situation.

I'm a reasonable shot with a handgun,,,
But it isn't because I have the best accessories,,,
It's because I shoot a lot of ammo practicing at the range.

Aarond

.
I will accept such a story from the owner of only one particular weapon. That is a Gen 1 Ruger P85 9mm. When I was attending the MoSHP's Firearms Instructor's Training there were two students who failed to qualify. Both had P85s. Now before you tsk, tsk know this; one of them was my roommate, a deputy from the county my muni agency was located in. I decided to shoot a qual course with it to see just how bad it was and brother, it sucked. I finished as the 5th best shooter in the class and I was only bested by 4 troopers who had their newly issued G22s with night sights. I couldn't see sh*take in the dark with my M66-1 so I can shoot. So anyway, that P85 sucked. Trigger, grip, sights the whole thing was a train wreck. I could have thrown it at the target and been more accurate. So there is one valid claim. The rest are as we all know weak excuses for lack of practice.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Top Bottom