Opinions on EFI to Carb conversion

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

cowadle

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Apr 11, 2009
Messages
3,454
Reaction score
4,608
Location
not available
We were just going to that very thing, on that very model of vehicle. Son bought a 90 F150 from a neighbor with a 300/5-speed, and it had sat forever. We were planning on new tanks (rusted out) and new fuel pumps, and swap a carb setup off of an earlier 300. We had just gotten rid of an intake and carb off of a 240 that would have worked, but in the end, the truck had title problems, and the neighbor was big enough to give his money back, and the project never materialized.

EFI is a thing of beauty, while it's working well. But on 20+ year old truck, a carb is so much easier to deal with, and troubleshoot.
i would just put an old style propane system on it. and ditch the gasoline.
 

montesa

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Feb 3, 2006
Messages
4,258
Reaction score
4,036
Location
OKC
I wouldn't do it. I'm around guys all the the time who are swapping engines into 66-77 broncos, carbs stay with carbs unless the carb is ditched for factory EFI or the occasional Holley EFI or Pro Flo EFI. I don't recall anyone swapping in a factory EFI engine and stripping it down to run a carb. Is there an intake manifold for that application or is a custom made deal?
Yes there’s lots of manifolds because the engine was carbed for many years before. Some recommend the offenhauser.

I may be better off leaving it as is unless I get around to installing a 300hp 351.
 

swampratt

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Nov 3, 2010
Messages
12,807
Reaction score
19,564
Location
yukon ok
I had 2 friends with the HO 351 and I tweaked one of them for more power with carb tweaking and timing curves.
It was in a 1984 E250 and I had a 302 .030" over in my 84E150 .
I added another overload spring and dual shocks up front and 3" lift at that time was on my 150.
He did not have any seats in his Van or interior except door panels other than driver and passenger. I had 4 captain chairs and a fold down bead and all carpeted head to toe.
Weight I would guess were about the same as they use the same frame .

I would out run him easy with the 306" ford but I did port my heads and ported the exhaust manifolds and intake manifold.
260H comp cam and 2 barrel carb , 3" single exhaust.
AOD in both of the vehicles my van averaged 17.6 MPG and I did not use the OD as it was too tall and I had 3.50 gears.

Other buddies 351HO was in a truck and it finally gave up and a 350" chevy was stuck into it and it had way more power everywhere.

My 306" after 13 years developed a miss and traced down to 1 cylinder that needed the valve lapped in.
Buddy needed a good engine and trans for his truck and ran a machine shop so I gave him that deal.

I then mocked up my E150 for a SBC.
Gas then went to 4 bucks a gallon and i parted the project out.
Was only me and the wife and she never went anywhere with me so I decided to get a Geo metro and jacked it up and painted it camo.

If you are going to swap something in there think really hard about what would work best for you.
I kind of wish i had put one of my 455 Olds engines into that Van.
But with gas so high I was shooting for 20 MPG.
Hard to get from a 6000 lb brick.
 

MP43

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Apr 27, 2007
Messages
429
Reaction score
378
Location
Siloam Springs, AR
I've had 150s with both EFI and carbed 300s, including a 300 with headers and a Holley 4 barrel on a Clifford aluminum intake. For all around drivability, power and economy, the EFI wins. Its not terribly difficult to set up a carb to beat EFI at one of those, but at the expense of the other two.
You can delete the smog pump and all its associated plumbing without hurting anything. Don't delete the the EGR unless you plan on reprogramming the computer. It doesn't hurt performance and will trip the CIL if its gone.
If you really want the EFI gone, go all the way and drop in a 351W. Gobs more power and torque and it'll bolt up to your existing transmission.
 

wolf_walker

Marksman
Special Hen
Joined
Aug 21, 2015
Messages
37
Reaction score
32
Location
OKC
I can appreciate not liking the mess under hood, especially if you can't identify what most of it is off hand, but there is no way on a stock or fairly stock motor I'd give up EFI if I was going to drive it year round and regularly. Someone else mentioned there is likely a lot of stuff you can get rid of and leave just the EFI.
I was the "Carb guy" amongst my buddies growing up and I can still rebuild and tune and have owned and driven daily everything from a 1 barrel to weirdo side draft multi carb European stuff, and worked on a ton more, 4+ cylinder motorcycles are another matter entirely and I own a digital carb sync tool, if that says anything. They perform better than you'd think, if you discount emissions, when they are in good order, but become a bloody headache after enough time or neglect just like anything else. And unless you're buying a Holley or some other known-brand new performance carb I shudder to think what you'd get as a "rebuilt" unit across the local McParts store counter these days with as low as the sales volume has got to be on them. Vintage/used units more often than not have worn throttle shafts sucking air or are an incorrectly jetted replacement installed decades ago so add that onto the pile of annoyance.
I like carbs, and if I was doing a weekend v8 car or some vintage euro stuff, sure nuff. But on a daily driver, EFI is the best thing since the round wheel, with the possible exception of non-points ignition.

All that said, is it not running right? It's plenty old enough to need some attention, and electronics, capacitors, resistors, drivers, etc such as are in the ECU, do fail from age.
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom