S&W Model 29 vs 629?

[docohm]

Saw a nice looking 629-1 8.375" barrel at a local place today. I really like the SS look and it had a nice trigger too. Very little wear. I'm thinking of trading in my 29-2 w/ 8.375" barrel for it. Mine also has the wooden case and cleaning tools. It's in very good condition also.
The 29 has more history (Dirty Harry movies) but the 629 looks better (to me). I'm no expert on revolvers, should I do it? And no, I can't have both! Wish I could...

 

[dlbleak]

I don't know, something about classic wood and blue. The presentation case has value by itself, even more of you have the tools. Research the variations of the screw driver that come with the tools. Some are more valuable than others. I would keep the box and see if they'll trade guns straight up if you want the stainless.

 

[1911master]

I prefer blue revolvers but that's just me.

 

[Gunbuffer]

youd be giving up the pinned and recessed features of the -2; I wouldn't do it, no way, never trade a early 60's SW for a 80's build!!!!??

 

[dlbleak]

youd be giving up the pinned and recessed features of the -2; I wouldn't do it, no way, never trade a early 60's SW for a 80's build!!!!??

Very good point GB.

 

[bigchuck83]

I'd keep the blue one myself. Unless you really must have the stainless, if so then sell the model 29 and buy the 629

 

[okiebertt]

I would keep the 29 and save up for the 629. If you trade off the 29 you will regret it one day.

 

[druryj]

Make the trade; it's not like it's a life or death decision, and if it makes you happy, well...you'll be happy.

 

[Hangfire]

Keep the 29 and put the 629 on lay-a-way.

 

[docohm]

OK! OK! You guys have talked me out of it. I'll keep the 29. Now I must decide if I want to put the 629 or the 929 PC on layaway! I didn't tell ya about the 929 PC, it's sweet! Maybe a 'go fund me' page so I can buy both?