9mm 1911 vs Browning Hi Power

[jbrentd]

I've been thinking about getting a Rock Island 9mm 1911 in the future, but the Browning Hi Power is also a consideration. The 1911 has been on my mind since buying our GSG 1911-22. The 1911 is just a good fit for me.

But I know nothing about all of the variations of BHPs models, and there seem to a lot of them. Are there any recommended starter BHPs that won't break the bank?

Also, please feel free to cuss and discuss the pro and cons of a 9mm 1911 vs BHPS. If anyone has a link to some good reading material on the subject, please point me in the right direction.

 

[Shootin 4 Fun]

I have a RIA 9mm that is functions flawlessly and accurate. I just purchased a Springfield EMP 9mm. The 9mm 1911 is the greatest creation since the 45acp 1911.

 

[TwoForFlinching]

I love the EMP! Never had one of my own, but I've shot a lot of them. But in a world between RIA 1911-9, and the browning hipower, browning is going to win hands down every day.

 

[preokc]

The 1911 in 9MM doesnt make much sence to me IMHO. 8 rounds of 45 ACP is one thing but one of the advantages of 9MM to me is twice the capacity which you dont get with a 1991 in 9MM.

 

[NikatKimber]

The 1911 in 9MM doesnt make much sence to me IMHO. 8 rounds of 45 ACP is one thing but one of the advantages of 9MM to me is twice the capacity which you dont get with a 1991 in 9MM.

It's not a practical carry gun, but they're an awesome range / competition shooter.

I love mine!

It's not a RIA though.

 

[Shootin 4 Fun]

The 1911 in 9MM doesnt make much sence to me IMHO. 8 rounds of 45 ACP is one thing but one of the advantages of 9MM to me is twice the capacity which you dont get with a 1991 in 9MM.

Oh yeah, tell us how 45acp self defense out performs 9mm self defense ammo.

 

[preokc]

Oh yeah, tell us how 45acp self defense out performs 9mm self defense ammo.

Honestly i dont know as ive never shot anybody. Even a 22 is lethal if shot placement is precise. Just saying BTW just get a FNH FNP/FNX 45 which has a 15 round mag and get the best of both worlds lol

 

[Cowman]

If the 1911 is your main carry platform. I would think the 9mm 1911 would be worth consideration. Otherwise I would go with the Browning. One of the best natural pointing handguns ever made. Regards.

 

[CHenry]

I have both but my browning is my fav. The 9mm 1911 is a taurus and is really nice but the browning shines over it.

 

[Jeff Hughes]

A "starter" BHP is an Arcus 94...