1st 1911 decision. Need advice

[septic_shock]

I've been thinking about picking up my first 1911. I had a chance to handle two guns that I liked: ruger sr1911 and a springfield parkerized mil spec. I walked out of the store because I just couldn't decide. I prefer the classic look of the mil spec, but wasn't sure if I would need a beaver tail or not, like what is found on the ruger. The ruger is nice with all the standard stuff.
I'm also wondering about the sights. The ruger has novaks, butt the springer is staked. They both looked fine me, but I know that it is a major hassle to change the sights on the mil spec.
What do you think? I would like to make either of these guns my primary carry. Any other models I should look at?

 

[surjimmy]

If you are going to use it as a primary carry, then get the Ruger. Not sure of the price at your store, but Do Not pay more then $700 OTD.

 

[Lurkerinthewoods]

I had two Springfield GI models, one full size and one commander. Got sick of getting brass in the face. Bought the Ruger SR1911 for around 620.00 and never looked back. Shoots like a dream and the upgrades over the Springfield were well worth it.

Out of stock for now, but shows what to expect in pricing.

http://www.gunbuyer.com/p-60872-rug...rrel-wood-grip-stainless-81.aspx#.U-lX-su9KSM

 

[septic_shock]

Upgrades aside (which is important none the less), would you consider the ruger to be equal in quality of fit and materials? I know some people make a big deal about cast vs forged frames. But as far as I know ruger knows how to make a damn good casting.
Am I over thinking this, lol?

 

[septic_shock]

By the way, thanks for the link.

 

[Lurkerinthewoods]

Upgrades aside (which is important none the less), would you consider the ruger to be equal in quality of fit and materials? I know some people make a big deal about cast vs forged frames. But as far as I know ruger knows how to make a damn good casting.
Am I over thinking this, lol?

The slide fit on the ruger is tight and smooth and the finish was flawless. To be fair, the Springfield fit and finish was tight as well. I would do a quick comparison, but after shooting the SR1911, I sold both my Springfields.

 

[Lurkerinthewoods]

I might also add, the Rock Island is a solid entry level 1911 for about half the price. I currently own 2 of those, one mil-spec and one tactical. My tactical model came with rubber grips.


http://www.slickguns.com/product/rock-island-1911-45-acp-tactical-handgun-41999

 

[surjimmy]

IMHO, the Ruger is the best buy out there for the money in the 1911 world. With everything you get, the Ruger should cost $800 plus.

 

[1911master]

Listen to surjimmy, he knows what he is talking about. And for the record I agree, the Ruger is a bargin.

 

[Grindstone]

I might also add, the Rock Island is a solid entry level 1911 for about half the price. I currently own 2 of those, one mil-spec and one tactical. My tactical model came with rubber grips.


http://www.slickguns.com/product/rock-island-1911-45-acp-tactical-handgun-41999

Seconded on the RIA. Every review I've seen puts it either on par or above high-dollar, big-name 1911s. You don't need a big name or a big price tag to get quality.