That's a good point. On the one hand I would say no we should not. Then I get to thinking why should we infringe on the rights of those citizens just because their state government is wrong.... states that don't recognize ours?
I'm currently on travel to a state that does not honor any other state's carry permits, so perhaps understandably it pisses me off that we as a state would grant rights for carry in our home to those folks. On the other hand, that whole "shall not be infringed" thing. Would barring carry to those outsiders perhaps incite a change of that state's policy?
So, just curious, what do others think? Should we as a state allow citizens of another state to carry in ours when they don't grant us the same courtesy?