I agree. The Judge is not the best carry gun. It would be useful while in the woods to defend against snakes and such. Federal has a coulpe of shot shells made specifically for pistols. You might try them and see if they pattern better. I don't own a Judge, but have shot some of my friends.
Dad and I thought about that because we have seen them in the past, before ammo was such a pain to find. Recently I haven't seen much in the way of any 410 shells at all. The stuff we shot this weekend was some El Cheapo stuff he found at a pawn shop. I'll tell him to keep an eye out for some marked especially for pistols. I am wondering if maybe a 2.5" shells would group better. I'm sure those Federals for handguns aren't the 3" variety.