Look at residual value on a Toyota and then look at the Ford, Chevy, and Dodge trucks and that was my initial reason. My builder has all newer F250 4x4s and my 08 Tundra pulled them out of the mud and up hills during my house construction on a regular basis.
That's just it though, toyota resale isn't any higher. IIRC Chevy still has the highest resale value in the truck market, dodge having the lowest (go figure) LOL.
Not to mention Toyota has the highest sticker prices and offer the least in rebates and incentives. Most dealers in this area won't come but a couple hundred off sticker. If you hit it right and you got buddies in the right places it ain't nothing to get $10-15k knocked off a ford or chevy. Now take any of those trucks, identical style, options and mileage (ford/chevy/Yota) a couple years after you bought it and the resale/trade in value will be pretty close.
As for any make of truck pulling others out the mud/hills more often. To claim that is comical...
I've gotten them all stuck LOL