If you could pick one.

[mr ed]

If I was going to shoot it. The Savage no question.
Nobody really collects Savage commemoratives, so theres no real value lost by shooting it.
The Winchesters look pretty hanging on the wall.
BUT! If they don't have the boxes and all the papers or if they have been shot they are worth no more than or maybe even less than a standard run of the mill Winchester 30-30.

 

[AKguy1985]

i'd pick the savage

 

[Shifty]

Savage for the cal.

But Im not one for safe queens, all mine are shooters.