Have you ever tired to make hard boiled eggs, but...

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Oklahomabassin

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Mar 27, 2007
Messages
25,118
Reaction score
23,957
Location
America!
OK, Dennis...

...give up the secret recipe for amount of water and/or temperatures. Wife has been trying every other method to getting easy to peel hard boiled eggs. I think the pressure cooker is the only thing she hasn't tried.
Simple. Use eggs that are a week or 2 old before boiling. No special fancy gizmo needed either.
 

tRidiot

Perpetually dissatisfied
Special Hen
Joined
Oct 23, 2009
Messages
19,521
Reaction score
12,712
Location
Bartlesville
Yes, fresh eggs are harder to peel. My problem with the undercooking was I didn't check the time. I had to do some things and was coming and going, didn't want to overcook them and thought I was 'estimating' about 10 minutes. Seems like it was probably 4 or so minutes short. Maybe 5.

Yeah, it was dumb.
 

swampratt

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Nov 3, 2010
Messages
12,812
Reaction score
19,592
Location
yukon ok
I am an EXPERT on boiling eggs.

Listen to me here and never have a failed boiled egg again.
Ok so maybe 2-3 in 100 boiled eggs will fail.

I have boiled over 400 eggs in the last year and it is not rocket science.

Fresh eggs laid that day are easy to peel just like store bought eggs.

Get the water to 200 degrees or boiling 200 is about when the tiny bubbles are about to become big bubbles.
Now take a spoon and place the egg in the spoon and gently lower it into the water not allowing it to crack on the bottom of the pan.

This cooks the inner peeling to she shell and makes the egg super easy to peel.

Now refrigerated eggs will need 10 minutes in the water while it is at a slow boil.
I adjust the heat so the water is not rolling and flopping out of the pan.

This 10 minutes will leave a firm but orange yolk no runny to it.
Dump the hot water and eggs into the sink after 10 minutes and run cold water on them so you can pick the egg up.

Or just let it sit there and cool down.
Now Tap Tap Tap Tap Tap that egg all around the shell and run water over it.
Start peeling the shell off.
It almost wants to fall off.
If you Tap it under running water it is even better.

DO NOT place eggs in cold water and then add the heat. This will make peeling quite a chore.

8 minutes Boil time will have soft almost some runny yolk.
4 minutes will be all runny yolk and all cooked white.
I had one of the 4 minute eggs yesterday.

Like peeling what felt like a water balloon.

Adjust time for room temp eggs.
9 minutes instead of 10.

Always place eggs in boiling water never cold for easy peel eggs.

I could have just said that.
 

trekrok

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Mar 6, 2009
Messages
3,657
Reaction score
6,072
Location
Yukon, OK
Here's my process. Eggs in pot, bring to a rapid boil, remove from heat and cover for 10-11 minutes. Dump water and fill with cold, then add ice. Let set a few minutes. I found this eliminates the green layer around the yolk.

However, ease of peeling them depends on freshness of eggs. Fresh still aren't fun to peel.
 

ConstitutionCowboy

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Jul 5, 2006
Messages
6,285
Reaction score
5,184
Location
Kingfisher County
I go with a ham and cheese omelet every morning unless we're having bacon and fried eggs. Eh ... Except for the cheese, it's pretty much the same thing ...

As far as soft boiled eggs are concerned, I prefer them in chicken-egg salad. That said, I haven't had chicken-egg salad with soft boiled eggs in many years since the wife likes hard boiled eggs in the chicken-egg salad. Her salad is so good the way she doctors it up, I'll keep my preference for soft boiled eggs in it at bay. My form of chicken-egg salad only has those two chicken parts in it anyway. Her's is better.

Deviled eggs are another exception to using soft boiled eggs. They gotta be hard boiled.

Woody
 

ConstitutionCowboy

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Jul 5, 2006
Messages
6,285
Reaction score
5,184
Location
Kingfisher County
I am an EXPERT on boiling eggs.

Listen to me here and never have a failed boiled egg again.
Ok so maybe 2-3 in 100 boiled eggs will fail.

I have boiled over 400 eggs in the last year and it is not rocket science.

Fresh eggs laid that day are easy to peel just like store bought eggs.

Get the water to 200 degrees or boiling 200 is about when the tiny bubbles are about to become big bubbles.
Now take a spoon and place the egg in the spoon and gently lower it into the water not allowing it to crack on the bottom of the pan.

This cooks the inner peeling to she shell and makes the egg super easy to peel.

Now refrigerated eggs will need 10 minutes in the water while it is at a slow boil.
I adjust the heat so the water is not rolling and flopping out of the pan.

This 10 minutes will leave a firm but orange yolk no runny to it.
Dump the hot water and eggs into the sink after 10 minutes and run cold water on them so you can pick the egg up.

Or just let it sit there and cool down.
Now Tap Tap Tap Tap Tap that egg all around the shell and run water over it.
Start peeling the shell off.
It almost wants to fall off.
If you Tap it under running water it is even better.

DO NOT place eggs in cold water and then add the heat. This will make peeling quite a chore.

8 minutes Boil time will have soft almost some runny yolk.
4 minutes will be all runny yolk and all cooked white.
I had one of the 4 minute eggs yesterday.

Like peeling what felt like a water balloon.

Adjust time for room temp eggs.
9 minutes instead of 10.

Always place eggs in boiling water never cold for easy peel eggs.

I could have just said that.

I just convinced the wife to try this method of making hard boiled eggs. Well ... Eh ... YOU convinced my wife to try this method of making hard boiled eggs. Thank you!

Woody
 

dennishoddy

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Dec 9, 2008
Messages
84,874
Reaction score
62,684
Location
Ponca City Ok
OK, Dennis...

...give up the secret recipe for amount of water and/or temperatures. Wife has been trying every other method to getting easy to peel hard boiled eggs. I think the pressure cooker is the only thing she hasn't tried.
Just a cup of water, put eggs on the trivet.
The instapot has a preset program for eggs. Pretty much takes care of everything.
ice water bath afterwards.
 

LBnM

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
1,493
Reaction score
696
Location
OKC
I am an EXPERT on boiling eggs.

Listen to me here and never have a failed boiled egg again.
Ok so maybe 2-3 in 100 boiled eggs will fail.

I have boiled over 400 eggs in the last year and it is not rocket science.

Fresh eggs laid that day are easy to peel just like store bought eggs.

Get the water to 200 degrees or boiling 200 is about when the tiny bubbles are about to become big bubbles.
Now take a spoon and place the egg in the spoon and gently lower it into the water not allowing it to crack on the bottom of the pan.

This cooks the inner peeling to she shell and makes the egg super easy to peel.

Now refrigerated eggs will need 10 minutes in the water while it is at a slow boil.
I adjust the heat so the water is not rolling and flopping out of the pan.

This 10 minutes will leave a firm but orange yolk no runny to it.
Dump the hot water and eggs into the sink after 10 minutes and run cold water on them so you can pick the egg up.

Or just let it sit there and cool down.
Now Tap Tap Tap Tap Tap that egg all around the shell and run water over it.
Start peeling the shell off.
It almost wants to fall off.
If you Tap it under running water it is even better.

DO NOT place eggs in cold water and then add the heat. This will make peeling quite a chore.

8 minutes Boil time will have soft almost some runny yolk.
4 minutes will be all runny yolk and all cooked white.
I had one of the 4 minute eggs yesterday.

Like peeling what felt like a water balloon.

Adjust time for room temp eggs.
9 minutes instead of 10.

Always place eggs in boiling water never cold for easy peel eggs.

I could have just said that.
I started doing this over a year ago and have NEVER had an egg difficult to peel. I was told 14 minutes for a true Hard boiled egg. It works. Ice bath to stop cooking at end of that time. With just cold water they will cook a little more so your time would work
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom