I don't think the quality of Catwoman's face is exactly what the producers had in mind. Look above to the catwoman screen shot. Now who would look better in a getup like that? Anne Hathaway or Nebras....I mean, Keira Knightly
Hands down, I'd choose Option #3:
Granted she may not be the best actress of the three, but let's face it, Catwoman isn't exactly a deep character.