I just gave up on another ink jet printer due to high costs of ink and repeated issues with using cheaper refills from Cartridge World.
I bought an HP LaserJet P1102w at Office Depot on sale for $99 and it's been the best decision I ever made in a printer. It's a B&W only and I just use it for generic printing and shipping invoices, labels, etc... but it's impressed me so far and I wouldn't hesitate to get a color version.
The nice thing is that it gives 1500 pages on a toner cartridge and I've found factory HP ones for as low as $65 and refills for as low as $26. That makes it significantly cheaper than the BS I've been putting up with on inkjets.
I'm a laser man till death now. Fast, cheap, good. It does all three better than an inkjet.
That is the exact printer I bought this summer. They are great! handy to have the printer in the office and print from anywhere in the house. +1 on not going inkjet. You basically buy the cartridge and throw the printer away.