Greatest Handgun of All Time ?

[Shadowrider]

That was a kinda tough call between the two Colts. But the 1911 wins out in my mind. Just too widespread with absolutely everyone making copies. Even Sig!

 

[Ignored Member]

I went with 1911, but I really like the Beretta 92fs too.

 

[Stephen Cue]

Id rank these (just the ones youve listed here) in order with special consideration for their eras.

1. 5'' 1911 Government
2. Colt SAA
3. Glock 17
4. Beretta 92
5. S&W J-frame
6. S&W 629
7. Browning HP
8. H&K USP
9. Sig P226
10. Ruger Blackhawk

I would have also added the Kel-tec .380 since they created a paradigm shift in the mouse gun species.

Ruger Marks .22lr should also be in a "greatest" roster.

 

[MadDogs]

Tough call. Don't think I could pick a "greatest" much less a favorite. Have shot or own some of the selection ....
Belgium Browning HP custom tuned by Austin Behlert
Series 70 Colt Combat Commander also tuned by Austin Behlert
S&W 4" 629 (no dash) tuned by MagNaPort
While not the P226, shown are my SIG P220 & Browning BDA, both in 45ACP.

 

[BReeves]

Had to go with the Browning HP.

 

[AKguy1985]

1911 gets my vote

 

[spd67]

I would have picked a 1911 4 inch..but there wasn't a choice..so I guess I'll go with the 5 inch....Though I am torn between that and the J frame. There is just something sexy about a J frame...

 

[John Zane]

I am a glock guy but I voted 1911. The polls asked for the greatest not the most reliable.

 

[bulbboy]

not my favorite but I would have to go with the 1911. 100 years with the same basic design -

 

[aod93gt]

I didn't vote; it would be a toss-up between the top 3 listed.