M&P45 vs 1911

[MBB]

Well, I chose the Colt Combat Elite. It cost more, but I got a good deal and I think I'll be happier with this one.

http://www.okshooters.com/forums/showthread.php?p=1189913#post1189913

 

[TonyT]

If i were going to carry a full size 45 A~CP then I would opt for the M&P45 over any 1911. In a carry gun I want one without external safeties or hammer. I shoot both 1911'a ans S&W M&P's in competition.

Is it worth the extra $300-400 to get the 1911 that I want vs getting an M&P45?


I have no reservations on reliability or maintainability for either. The M&P isn't as pretty, but it seems to be much more practical with 2 more rounds of capacity and price.


I have an M&P9c and love it. I've shot friends' M&P45s and loved them too. I like shooting 1911s and it is a timeless design.


I plan to carry this weapon. I'd get a 4" M&P or a 5" steel 1911.

Should I catch up with the times and go with polymer or stay in a bygone era that I didn't even experience myself?