Seeking Advice on Firearm Sales Throught the Classifieds

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

nemesis

Sharpshooter
Joined
May 12, 2010
Messages
1,102
Reaction score
485
Location
tulsa
Also, if anyone has some other good tips about the process, I would greatly appreciate any and all comments.

My above post deals with face to face. You might also consider selling the gun on gunbroker.com. Without going into the specifics of pricing, reserve/no reserve, minimum starting price, etc, the advantage of gunbroker is that you can ship the gun through a local FFL. You can also specify the buyer pays all shipping/transfer fees. I like this method. There is a clear paper trail from where the gun originates all the way to where it's going. If there is ever an issue with what happens to the gun, you've got documentation showing that it left your possession.
 

CAR-AR-M16

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Sep 6, 2005
Messages
5,824
Reaction score
309
Location
Duncan
Unless this "documentation" is notarized, it would not prove anything and is really unnecessary. There have been other threads on here where members were contacted be LE because a gun they sold was used in a crime (one was actually a murder). None remembered the details of the sale and it was non-issue as far as LE was concerned.
 

Keelty

Sharpshooter
Joined
Jun 29, 2007
Messages
11,882
Reaction score
10
Location
Broken Arrow
Your local FFL keeps the hard copies of the 4473s for as long as he is in business. If he goes out of business the 4473s go to the BATFE. We say Oklahoma has no registration system. What I've just mentioned is, in fact, a form of registration.

FFL has to keep them for 20 years. After that, the FFL may destroy them.

The 4473 do go to the BATFE if the dealer goes out of business.

If the firearm is registered wouldn't you have a title or form to prove you own the firearm? I sell a bunch of firearms and never once has a customer left with a title or form proving they own the firearm.
 

farmerbyron

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Nov 3, 2008
Messages
5,289
Reaction score
152
Location
Tuttle
Unless this "documentation" is notarized, it would not prove anything and is really unnecessary. There have been other threads on here where members were contacted be LE because a gun they sold was used in a crime (one was actually a murder). None remembered the details of the sale and it was non-issue as far as LE was concerned.


^^^^Ditto.

According to some guys here, we may as well have UBC already. I just don't see why you have the need to CYA if you have done nothing wrong or illegal.
 

tRidiot

Perpetually dissatisfied
Special Hen
Joined
Oct 23, 2009
Messages
19,521
Reaction score
12,715
Location
Bartlesville
Unless this "documentation" is notarized, it would not prove anything and is really unnecessary. There have been other threads on here where members were contacted be LE because a gun they sold was used in a crime (one was actually a murder). None remembered the details of the sale and it was non-issue as far as LE was concerned.

^^^^Ditto.

According to some guys here, we may as well have UBC already. I just don't see why you have the need to CYA if you have done nothing wrong or illegal.

So many people are worried about being hassled in the event a firearm they sell is eventually used in a crime. Here's my take on it.

Police show up at the door. "Umm, sir, a trace of a firearm used in a crime over in *XXXXX locality* led to a dealer who received that firearm from the manufacturer. That dealer searched through his 4473s and told us he sold that firearm to you 9 years ago."

Citizen - "Ok. Which firearm are we talking about?"

LEO - "Well, sir, it was a *XXXXX model* in *XX caliber* serial number *XXXXX*. Do you currently have possession of this firearm?"

Citizen - "No, sorry, I do remember owning a gun of that description, but I am pretty sure I sold that to a private individual at a gunshow 4 or 5 years ago... I don't remember which show, and I had no reason to believe he was a felon, so I proceeded with the legal private sale."

LEO - "Ok, sir, we're sorry to bother you, but would you mind answering just a few more questions so we can try to exclude you and move forward in our investigation?"

Citizen - "Sure thing."

LEO - "Do you know Mr. *XXXXX* who was murdered/robbed/assaulted, or do you have any connections to him, his family, business or associates?"

Citizen - "Nope, never heard of him."

LEO - "One more thing, sir, were you anywhere near *XXXXX locality* on the date in question, or can you show us that you were somewhere else?"

Citizen - "Sure, I was here at home with my wife/at work/out of town on business/etc. If you need to later on, I can come up with credit card bills or some other proof that I had no connection to this incident."

LEO - "Thank you, sir, if that becomes necessary, we will be in touch. Have a nice day, and thank you for your assistance. If you happen to remember anything useful regarding the individual who legally purchased this firearm from you, we'd sure appreciate your cooperation in helping solve this crime. Please contact us if you do remember anything."

Citizen - "Absolutely, I'll do all I can to help lock up these scumbag criminals who are preying on our society."

LEO - "Thank you again, sir, and have a nice day."

Citizen - "You're welcome, Officer, and good luck catching the SOB."



Personally, I think this is eminently better than:

Police show up at the door. "Umm, sir, a trace of a firearm used in a crime over in *XXXXX locality* led to a dealer who received that firearm from the manufacturer. That dealer searched through his 4473s and told us he sold that firearm to you 9 years ago."

Citizen - "I'm sorry, I don't answer questions of that nature. You'll need to contact my attorney. Here is his name and number."

Door slams.

Now... I will stipulate that some people will tell you that even this amount of questioning is intrusive and you should not answer anything. Personally, if I know I've done nothing wrong, being polite and helpful in their efforts will do nothing but help exclude me as a suspect, and in general, it seems the odds are pretty astronomical that any crime committed in this fashion could by pure chance be tied to me individually in a way I was both implicated as a suspect in some way other than having once owned the firearm in question and had motive, opportunity and was at the same time unable to provide means to exclude myself as a suspect.

Pretty far-fetched, though not impossible.

Personally... I don't worry about it. I'd rather not be burdened with keeping any records, or have my information stored by an individual I don't know and who will do who knows what with my info.

Let's say you do keep those records as a seller... and over 10 years you've sold.... oh, let's say 25 firearms. If they come knocking and you pull out your file and you happen to have all of the records, except maybe that one your 2-y/o used for drawing paper, or the dog ate it, or it just plain disappeared. Then, it becomes a question of, "Sir, we see here that you have records of selling a number of your firearms, but this particular one is not in the stack. Can you explain why you are so motivated to keep such records, but the one particular one we're looking for isn't here?" Almost make for more suspicion.

It's all or none, I think... and for me, personally, it's none. Although, if you wish to do so, I support your right 100%.
 

tntrex

Sharpshooter
Joined
Jan 19, 2010
Messages
3,379
Reaction score
4
Location
Altus
I swear some people need to just crawl back under your rocks and be scared of your gawd damned shadows

or

go join the progressive movement
 

Cedar Creek

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
May 31, 2010
Messages
1,378
Reaction score
15
Location
SW Oklahoma
I've done firearms business with OSA members through the classified and have always been totally satisfied. I bought one single action revolver off Armslist from a CAS shooter from Little Axe and it went fine. Looked into possible transactions a couple times on Armslist and just gave it up totally. Armslist is pretty much a cesspool as far asw I'm concerned - a few good people surrounded by crooks and incompetent sellers.

OSA is the way to go for buying/selling firearms & gear as far as I'm concerned. If someone wanted my to write them out a bill of sale for something I was selling I'd be fine with that. As a buyer - if terms of sale include my personal info, showing ID, etc. I will not participate. I think it is a great idea that people who feel differently include that info in their seller's post to avoid wasted time on the part of both parties.

Cedar Creek
 

druryj

In Remembrance / Dec 27 2021
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
Jan 16, 2010
Messages
21,469
Reaction score
17,726
Location
Yukon, OK
I have bought ,sold and traded a bunch with people here and on armslist.way better people to deal with here. I have never had a problem,but I'm always polite,professional and have a plan to kill everyone I meet.

Dang Dude; no wonder I'm always so nervous :yikes2: doing bidness with you! Here I am just trying to buy/sell or trade yet another gun/holster/or some ammo with you and your thinkin' about killin' me! Yikes!:fullauto:
 

TerryMiller

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Jun 4, 2009
Messages
19,026
Reaction score
19,213
Location
Here, but occasionally There.
I have bought ,sold and traded a bunch with people here and on armslist.way better people to deal with here. I have never had a problem,but I'm always polite,professional and have a plan to kill everyone I meet.

Dang Dude; no wonder I'm always so nervous :yikes2: doing bidness with you! Here I am just trying to buy/sell or trade yet another gun/holster/or some ammo with you and your thinkin' about killin' me! Yikes!:fullauto:

Yeee...gads!!!! I missed that one.

(Note to self.....don't sell to Saddlebum. If he PM's, withdraw the ad.)
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom