Nashville School Shooting

[TerryMiller]

Actually you can't say that (without being ripped apart by some) because doctors feel that is something they can change by surgery. If doctors truly felt it was a mental disorder they would actually treat the mental illness part of it rather than expensive ineffective surgery and a lifetime of meds. Suicide rate among trans people is much higher from what I have heard and surgeries have lifelong issues that continually need surgical repair.

It is more of an issue because of the "beliefs" of the American Psychiatric Association. As with some other "abnormalities," the APA chose to determine that trans-people weren't having psychiatric issues and deemed them as normal. I guess that before they did that, they did believe that trans-people did have mental issues.

 

[Matt72]

Something I've always wondered, how many of these murderers are on some type of anti depression drug. Seems like a lot of young people are on them and I remember when prozac came out there were a couple of murders but I have not found any investigation on the types of drugs these shooters are on. I always wondered if big pharma has a role but can't find any data

 

[TerryMiller]

Interesting that regular gay people are starting to turn against trans people.

https://www.powerlineblog.com/archives/2023/03/the-culture-war-about-to-become-violent.php

It was interesting to me, and welcomed by me, that when they had that shooting in Florida in a gay bar that folks in the gay community decided that they also needed to have firearms in order to protect themselves. I'm all for sane people having the desire to own firearms.

 

[TANSTAAFL]

Something I've always wondered, how many of these murderers are on some type of anti depression drug. Seems like a lot of young people are on them and I remember when prozac came out there were a couple of murders but I have not found any investigation on the types of drugs these shooters are on. I always wondered if big pharma has a role but can't find any data

Big part of it I would imagine. In this case as I said earlier, wonder if she was on testosterone. If she was, prescription or self medication. Sadly we will never know.

 

[TANSTAAFL]

It is more of an issue because of the "beliefs" of the American Psychiatric Association. As with some other "abnormalities," the APA chose to determine that trans-people weren't having psychiatric issues and deemed them as normal. I guess that before they did that, they did believe that trans-people did have mental issues.

APA helping out their buddies at the ASA.

 

[TerryMiller]

APA helping out their buddies at the ASA.

ASA?

I guess I'm not familiar with that association.

 

[okcBob]

It is more of an issue because of the "beliefs" of the American Psychiatric Association. As with some other "abnormalities," the APA chose to determine that trans-people weren't having psychiatric issues and deemed them as normal. I guess that before they did that, they did believe that trans-people did have mental issues.

APA is a liberal organization that many of their positions are political .

 

[elwoodtrix]

Actually you can't say that (without being ripped apart by some) because doctors feel that is something they can change by surgery. If doctors truly felt it was a mental disorder they would actually treat the mental illness part of it rather than expensive ineffective surgery and a lifetime of meds. Suicide rate among trans people is much higher from what I have heard and surgeries have lifelong issues that continually need surgical repair.

Dr.s are afraid of being sued for not treating these children that's why they are allowing it.

 

[BobbyV]

Why do these things seem to always happen right during a big gun control discussion in DC . . .

 

[JoeUSooner]

It is more of an issue because of the "beliefs" of the American Psychiatric Association. As with some other "abnormalities," the APA chose to determine that trans-people weren't having psychiatric issues and deemed them as normal. I guess that before they did that, they did believe that trans-people did have mental issues.

Every psychiatrist in America (to keep the license) MUST themselves undergo regular psychiatric therapy. What does that tell you when every shrink has to have one of his or her own?